Correction and Retraction Policy

Pharmatera Journal is committed to maintaining the accuracy, credibility, transparency, and integrity of the scientific literature. The journal recognizes that errors, inaccuracies, or ethical concerns may be identified after an article has been published. Therefore, Pharmatera Journal has established a Correction and Retraction Policy in accordance with the principles and guidelines recommended by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

This policy ensures that errors and research misconduct are addressed fairly, transparently, and responsibly to preserve the reliability of the published scientific record.

1. Correction of Published Articles

Corrections may be issued when errors or inaccuracies are identified in a published article but do not substantially affect the reliability, validity, or overall conclusions of the research.

Corrections may be necessary in cases involving:

  1. Errors in data presentation, tables, figures, or statistical calculations that do not invalidate the main findings.

  2. Incorrect or incomplete author information, institutional affiliations, or acknowledgments.

  3. Errors in references, citations, or other bibliographic information.

  4. Inaccuracies in research methodology descriptions that require clarification without affecting the validity of the study.

  5. Other unintentional errors that may influence the interpretation or understanding of the published article.

When a significant error is identified, authors are responsible for promptly notifying the Editorial Board of Pharmatera Journal.

The Editorial Board will evaluate the reported error and determine whether a formal correction is necessary.

A correction notice will be published and linked to the original article to ensure transparency and maintain the accuracy of the scientific record.

2. Retraction of Published Articles

Retraction is a formal mechanism used to correct the scientific literature when a published article contains serious errors, unreliable findings, or substantial violations of publication ethics.

Pharmatera Journal may consider retracting an article under the following circumstances:

  1. Research Misconduct: Evidence of data fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, or other serious violations of research integrity.

  2. Unreliable Findings: Significant errors in methodology, data analysis, or interpretation that invalidate the main conclusions of the research.

  3. Duplicate Publication: Substantial duplication of previously published material without appropriate disclosure or justification.

  4. Unethical Research Practices: Research conducted without required ethical approval, informed consent, or compliance with applicable ethical standards.

  5. Copyright Violations: Unauthorized use of copyrighted materials that cannot be adequately resolved through correction.

  6. Compromised Peer Review: Evidence of manipulation or misconduct that undermines the integrity of the peer-review process.

Retraction decisions will be based on the available evidence and the reliability and ethical status of the published research.

Retraction is intended primarily to correct the scientific record rather than to punish authors.

3. Retraction Procedure

When concerns regarding a published article are raised, Pharmatera Journal will conduct an appropriate investigation in accordance with COPE guidelines.

The procedure may include:

  1. Initial Assessment: The Editor-in-Chief or designated editor evaluates the reported concern and supporting evidence.

  2. Notification to Authors: The corresponding author and relevant co-authors are informed of the concerns and given an opportunity to provide explanations or supporting documentation.

  3. Editorial Investigation: The Editorial Board reviews relevant evidence and may consult independent experts, reviewers, or research institutions when necessary.

  4. Editorial Decision: Based on the investigation findings, the Editorial Board determines whether correction, retraction, an expression of concern, or another appropriate action is required.

  5. Publication of Retraction Notice: When retraction is warranted, the journal publishes a formal retraction notice explaining the reasons for the decision.

The journal may retract an article even when the authors do not agree with the decision, provided that sufficient evidence justifies the action.

4. Retraction Notice and Article Accessibility

When an article is retracted, Pharmatera Journal will publish a clear and accessible retraction notice.

The retraction notice will:

  1. Clearly identify the retracted article, including its title, authors, and publication details.

  2. Explain the reasons for retraction in an objective and transparent manner.

  3. Identify the party initiating the retraction, where appropriate.

  4. Be clearly labeled as a "Retraction" and linked to the original article.

  5. Remain publicly accessible to ensure transparency and preserve the scientific record.

Retracted articles will generally remain accessible in the journal's online archive but will be clearly marked as "Retracted."

Complete removal of published content will only be considered in exceptional circumstances, such as legal requirements, serious privacy violations, or risks to public safety.

5. Expression of Concern

Pharmatera Journal may issue an Expression of Concern when credible allegations raise significant doubts about the integrity or reliability of a published article but the available evidence is insufficient to justify an immediate retraction.

An Expression of Concern may be published when:

  1. An investigation into suspected research misconduct is ongoing.

  2. Available evidence is inconclusive or conflicting.

  3. An investigation by the authors' institution has not reached a definitive conclusion.

  4. Serious concerns about the reliability of research findings remain unresolved.

The Expression of Concern will be linked to the original article and may be updated or replaced by a correction or retraction notice when further evidence becomes available.

6. Author-Initiated Corrections and Retractions

Authors who identify substantial errors or ethical concerns in their published research are required to notify the Editorial Board promptly.

Requests for corrections or retractions must include a clear explanation of the problem and relevant supporting documentation.

The Editorial Board will evaluate each request independently and determine the appropriate action based on the nature and severity of the issue.

Authors are expected to cooperate fully with editorial assessments and corrective procedures.

7. Corrections and Retractions Initiated by Third Parties

Pharmatera Journal accepts credible reports of errors, ethical violations, or research misconduct from readers, reviewers, institutions, and other concerned parties.

Reports should include sufficient information to identify the article and explain the nature of the concern.

The Editorial Board will assess the allegations objectively and, when appropriate, contact the authors or relevant institutions for clarification.

The identity of individuals reporting concerns will be treated confidentially to the extent reasonably possible and consistent with applicable procedures.

8. Editorial Independence and Transparency

All correction and retraction decisions are made by the Editor-in-Chief and Editorial Board based on scientific evidence, ethical considerations, and established publication standards.

Editorial decisions must remain independent of commercial interests, institutional pressure, personal relationships, or other inappropriate influences.

Pharmatera Journal is committed to ensuring that all corrective actions are implemented fairly, consistently, and transparently.

9. Post-Publication Responsibilities

Authors, editors, reviewers, and the publisher share responsibility for maintaining the integrity of the published scientific record.

Authors must cooperate in addressing errors or ethical concerns identified after publication.

Editors are responsible for evaluating concerns, conducting appropriate assessments, and implementing necessary editorial actions.

The publisher supports the preservation, accessibility, and transparency of correction and retraction notices.

10. Commitment to Publication Integrity

Pharmatera Journal is dedicated to protecting the reliability and integrity of scientific publications through responsible correction and retraction practices.

All corrections, expressions of concern, and retractions will be handled in accordance with internationally recognized principles of publication ethics.

The journal remains committed to ensuring that published scientific information is accurate, trustworthy, and appropriately maintained as part of the scholarly record.

References:

  1. Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Retraction Guidelines and Publication Ethics Resources.
    https://publicationethics.org/

  2. International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE). Corrections, Retractions, Republications, and Version Control.
    https://www.icmje.org/recommendations/