Proses Peer Review

The Editor-in-Chief will assign the manuscript to the Managing Editor for further handling. The Managing Editor will request at least two scientists to review the research article manuscript. All manuscripts are subject to a double-blind peer review process—where the identities of both the reviewers and the authors are kept confidential from one another—to ensure adherence to standards of academic excellence.

Detailed information regarding the workflow from manuscript submission (by the author) to its receipt by the editor is illustrated in the following figure.

In short, the steps are as follows:

  1. Manuscript Submission (by the author) (path 1)
  2. Manuscript Screening and Selection (by the manager and editor) (path 2). The editor has the authority to accept, reject, or send the manuscript for review. Before any further processing, a plagiarism check using Turnitin is conducted for every manuscript.
  3. Manuscript Review Process (by reviewers) (paths 3–4)
  4. Notification of Acceptance, Revision, or Rejection (sent by the editor to the author, based on the reviewers' comments) (path 5)
  5. Revision of the Paper (by the author)
  6. Submission of Revisions based on Reviewer Suggestions (by the author), following the same procedure as in step 1 (path 1)
  7. If the reviewers are satisfied with the revisions, a notification of acceptance is issued (by the editor) (path 6)
  8. Proofreading and galley publication process (paths 7 and 8)

Steps 1 through 5 are considered one round of the peer-review process (see the shaded area in the image). The editor or editorial board considers the feedback provided by the peer reviewers and makes a decision. The following are the most common decisions:

  • Accepted, as is: The journal will publish the paper in its original form.
  • Accepted with minor revisions: The journal will publish the paper, provided the author makes minor corrections (the author is given a specified amount of time to carry out these revisions).
  • Accepted with major revisions: The journal will publish the paper, provided the author incorporates the changes suggested by the reviewers and/or the editor (the author is given a specified amount of time to carry out these revisions).
  • Resubmit (conditional rejection): The journal is willing to reconsider the paper in a subsequent round of decision-making, once the author has made major changes.
  • Rejected (outright rejection): The journal will not publish the paper, nor will it reconsider it, even if the author makes major revisions.